Supporting hardware companies that support software freedom

There’s 2 sets of issues here;

  1. What devices are available at all, and what are their pros and cons, considering not just software freedom, but also open hardware and repairability? The FSF’s Respects Your Freedom certification and LinuxPreloaded are good resources for finding companies and devices. EDIT: As is the list of vendors shipping variants of the CoreBoot BIOS replacement.
  2. What devices can be bought from retailers in Aotearoa, or shipped here with decent customer support?

Companies and devices community members have shared experiences with (in alphabetical order);

1 Like

I’ve had experience with;

  • ThinkPenguin: Sells laptops and a range of other hardware known to work with Trisquel and other 100% Free Code OS. Ordered a WiFi dongle sometime in 2016/17. The ordering process was easy, delivery fairly prompt, and after-sale customer service was excellent. Would buy from them again.
  • Pine64: Makers of PineBook, Pine Phone, PineTab, PineTime, etc. I ordered one of the first community edition PinePhones in 2020. The device was very cheap, the process was fairly simple, and delivery was prompt. Would buy from them again.

Other companies I’m aware of;

Nearly 20 years ago(!) I bought a laptop from system76 and they’re still operating - https://system76.com. It was fine.

I just looked at the prices though and they are eye-watering. Maybe that’s normal these days.

I’m guessing that’s do to with the MOLE Training con pushing the price of RAM though the ceiling?

EDIT: US$2000-ish seems to be the standard price for laptops roughly equivalent to a MacBook. ThinkPenguin has one for about US$1200, but I’m guessing that’s more minimal specs. Purism is at the more expensive end, closer to US$3000.

I’m not aware of any high-volume Linux laptop sellers (which would push the cost down) except, occasionally, Dell. But those are not available in Aotearoa NZ so far as I know. All the recent laptops I’ve bought for myself, family, and friends (at least half a dozen) have been ‘refurbished Thinkpads’, mostly Carbon X1s and T490s (I’m loving the latter) for between $500-$700… they come with 16GB RAM, and between 250-500GB storage… They’ve got plenty of power for most uses (not gaming, though)… But they do come with Windows. I’ve normally - pre ‘AI’ circus - put a new NVME drive (usually a TB) into them, and installing Linux on it. Then I reuse the Windows NVMEs (but not the Windows!) for smaller devices like Raspberry Pis or similar.

As you might have guessed @lightweight , paying for a Windows license - however indirectly - is a total showstopper for me now. That’s why I’ve generally made do with cheap used laptops. But that puts me on a treadmill of having to get a new laptop every few years, and it’s a crapshoot whether they’ll run Trisquel (a deblobbed Ubuntu distro endorsed by the FSF).

Plus, if we want more hardware that respects our freedom in the market, we need to prove there’s a demand for it, by buying it from the vendor when it’s available. Ideally from companies that share our tech values. So then our money is going into funding the development of more freedom-respecting hardware, which we can buy later, creating a virtuous cycle.

But that’s harder to do in a small country, thus this topic. I wonder if we could pool resources with our counterparts in Oz to get more freedom-respecting hardware available here with good customers support?

1 Like

I’ve had great experience with Purism devices:

  • Librem 14 (they are selling Librem 16 in its place now). Delivered in one month.
  • Librem 5 GNU/Linux phone - essentially an ARM computer with touchscreen and modem attached. Delivered in 2 weeks.

Their customer support is good, they always help but their reply can take anywhere from a few days to a week!

I’ve used PureOS (based on Debian) and Fedora on the laptop, and PureOS and postmarketOS phosh on the phone.

Purism’s PureOS is one of the few distros endorsed as completely free by the FSF.

1 Like

On this subject, I’ve thought many times about setting up a co-op hardware buyer for Aotearoa, to help people find out about rights-respecting devices, and get a hold of them. The MVP would be a website where people can see a curated set of recommended hardware, of different types, from a range of vendors who currently ship to Aotearoa, with links to the relevant ordering page on the vendor’s website.

But if that worked out, and there was sufficient interest, it ought to be possible to get a competent core group together and start handling orders on the co-op website, and taking a markup from sales. At that point it would probably make sense to start talking to the vendors about dealer accounts, bulk discounts, etc.

To get the volume to really make it work, it would probably be necessary to evangelize to small-to-medium businesses, and not-for-profit orgs, especially those who buy a new set of devices every couple of years. Individual buyers could then get access to a wide range of devices, at cheaper prices, coasting on that baseline.

EDIT: The co-op could also offer a classifieds service (using something like Flohmarket?) where vetted customers could sell unwanted gear that meets the co-op’s ethical hardware criteria, This could even be an intermediary stage between the simple recommendations and links site MVP, and the full online retailer stage. An initial version could just connect sellers and buyers of used stuff and walk away, but if an online store and payment system was set up, the co-op could perhaps provide some payment-handling infrastructure to facilitate these trades (eg an escrow service), modulo financial regulations, liability, etc.

The predictable enshittification of Android/Linux seems to have set off a Cambrian explosion of new mobile offerings. Including companies making commercial devices to run deGoggled Android out-of-the-box, or novel mobile OS like Mobile GNU.

One that’s new to me is Brax, which popped up recently in the Flounder Matrix room, specifically their Wink device, which apparently supports 5G calling, and has a physical keyboard :star_struck: Brax also have devices in more standard ‘phone’ and ‘tablet’ form factors. As well as a privacy-focused wall panel (Wall Up) that might interest @lightweight and anyone else using Home Assistant for domestic automation.

Keen on the co-op. Who’d carry warranty claims though, you or the vendor?

I may be missing some nuance of what you mean by;

But off the top of my head, the co-op would be the first port of call for customer support, but ultimately the vendor would have to stand behind the hardware they supply. If a problem can be resolved locally (eg simple software problems, replacing bad RAM or drive), so much the better. But the vendor would need to cover any replacement parts. Otherwise the co-op could facilitate sending the device for a repair or replace by the vendor, under the terms of both the warrant supplied and the Consumer Guarantees Act.

More data points on the potential value of the ethical hardware co-op idea.

Over the last week or so I’ve been trying to order a new laptop from ThinkPenguin. Their customer service, as always, has been fantastic. But even so, it’s been a fraught process, because of;

  • Prices on their website in US$, which caught me by surprise when I went through the ordering process, even though I ought to have expected it

  • Complications with sending large amounts of money cross-border (often gets caught in a thicket of KYC, anti-scam, and anti-money laundering systems)

  • Shop website errors, due to hasty changes made to address the recent PHP-ageddon

If I hadn’t read so many good things about ThinkPenguin on the Trisquel forums etc over the years, and had such a good experience with previous orders (about a decade ago), I may well have given up by now. Which would be a shame, because TP is exactly the kind of hardware company we need more of, with the kind of rights-respecting hardware we want to be getting into the hands of more kiwis.

Further complications came with getting from order to delivery. Again not ThinkPenguin’s fault, and their customer support continues to be stirling.

First, I got a text asking me to email someone I’d never heard of from Fliway.com, which I’d never heard of. I emailed TP about it and they poked around and found out that Fliway is a NZ “partner” (contractor) of UPS. They told me as long as they’re not asking for money (only UPS themselves ought to do that here), it was probably fine follow their instructions on paying any customs fees.

I emailed Fliway and they emailed back a PDF of an application form for an import number. Apparently I had to have one became the goods I’ve ordered are worth more than NZ$1000. The email said if I didn’t resolve the matter within 6 days, I could be charged for storage or the good could be abandoned, which was a bit freaky.

I couldn’t work out if the PDF was read/write using the libre apps I had on my mobile. So I ended up going to the library to print, fill out, sign, and scan it, and emailed it back. So far so good. The weekend passed.

On Monday I get an email from UPS with an invoice for customs fees, and some payment information. But the reference number was just a string of ####. Maybe the actual number hadn’t been inserted into the template?

Tuesday I get a nag email from UPS, which I didn’t see until after I saw a text from them that had the proper reference number. I’d seen on Monday email that internet banking was an option, so I used that. Now that I could actually make payment, I looked at the invoice. Around $500, almost 1/5 of the total value of the laptop, for the service of allowing the courier company to bring it into the country so be delivered. WTF?!

So this laptop, which I was originally looking at on a website and thinking it was $1000, has ended up costing me over $3000. Something I would have known in advance if I was ordering it through an Aotearoa-based web shop.

1 Like

I always use the Duty Estimator on the customs website to figure out the total approximate cost.
Purism uses DHL so they start all this while the package is on the way.
I think larger vendors like Dell pay all these and just factor in to the cost, that’s why if you order from them, you don’t have to deal with all this.

Aotearoa-based web shop

My definition of Year of the (GNU) Linux Desktop is when/where a person can just walk in to a reputable store, and just see and buy laptops preinstalled with Linux similarly like Windows, similar prices even if a bit higher, similar expectation of support, warranty, etc.

I think we need pro-FLOSS entrepreneurs just as much as we need the techies.

Maybe we need to start something like Thinkpenguin, Sendero Linux, etc ourselves here and across the pond. Refurbished Thinkpads with GNU/Linux preinstalled, cheap degoogled phones, etc.

Absolutely agree that’s the goal. The question is, how do we get from here to there?

The reason we don’t have this now is that retailers don’t believe there’s sufficient demand to justify the extra trouble and expense of offering GNU/Linux devices. Organising ourselves to create a retail layer as a co-op could be a way to prove the demand. As well as making it easier to buy such devices, without the risk of headaches like the ones I’ve described here, which may well increase the demand.

Setting up and maintaining a hardware vendor would be way more work than doing the same for a retail operation. But I would absolutely support that, and it would make sense for a buyers club co-op to put such a vendor’s products front and centre in its catalogue.